Monday, February 26, 2007

JIHAD IN ISLAM: REBUTTAL TO IBN WARRAQ

Page 217 Warraq then goes onto Jihad in Islam. Jihad does not mean Holy War, it actually means struggle. Heres a hadith that proves it:

Abu Sa’id Al-Khudri reported the Apostle of God as saying: “The best striving (Jihad) in the path of God is (to speak) a word of justice to an oppressive ruler” (Abu Dawud, hadith #4330)

So one can see that Jihad is struggle and does not mean war. As a matter of fact there is no holy war concept in Islam.

Warraq then rips verses out of context in order to prove his point. Here is one example. Warraq quotes the following Quranic verse:

But when the forbidden months are past, then fight and slay the Pagans wherever ye find them, an seize them, beleaguer them, and lie in wait for them in every stratagem (of war); but if they repent, and establish regular prayers and practise regular charity, then open the way for them: for Allah is Oft-forgiving, Most Merciful. (Quran 9:5)

The part I underlined was the part he quoted in his book. Notice the complete distortion of the Quranic text. What I have quoted is the full verse of the Quranic verse. However one must read the following verse of the Quran in order to get a full scope of what the Quran is teaching:

If one amongst the Pagans ask thee for asylum, grant it to him, so that he may hear the word of Allah; and then escort him to where he can be secure. That is because they are men without knowledge. (Quran 9:6)

One of the Pagans ask Prophet Muhammed or any other early Muslim, then they are told to grant it to him. It does not say kill the Pagan, rather it states grant him protection if he wants it.

Further verses Ibn Warraq quotes that promote “Holy war” as he says are: Quran 8:15-16, 9:39 and 4:74. Lets look further into them:

O ye who believe! when ye meet the Unbelievers in hostile array, never turn your backs to them. If any do turn his back to them on such a day - unless it be in a stratagem of war, or to retreat to a troop (of his own)- he draws on himself the wrath of Allah, and his abode is Hell,- an evil refuge (indeed)! (Quran 8:15-16)

Again, this verse is speaking about the battles against the Quraysh. It is not talking about modern day non-Muslims. Plus according to the Abdullah Yousef Ali commentary, this could even be reffering to a spiritual fight instead of physical.

Unless ye go forth, He will punish you with a grievous penalty, and put others in your place; but Him ye would not harm in the least. For Allah hath power over all things.( 9:39)

Nowhere in this verse is it speaking about fighing. Rarther its speaking about self defense as this verse points out:

Pagans all together as they fight you all together. But know that Allah is with those who restrain themselves. (Quran 9:36). So this is speaking about the Pagans. It also states that Allah is with those who restrain themselves. So the Quran is speaking about self defense in these verses.

Regarding the last verse 4:74, it reads:

Let those fight in the cause of Allah Who sell the life of this world for the hereafter. To him who fighteth in the cause of Allah,- whether he is slain or gets victory - Soon shall We give him a reward of great (value).

Again, another verse telling self defense as these verses point out:

"Fight in the cause of God those who fight you, but do not transgress limits; for God loveth not transgressors. (The Noble Quran, 2:190)"
"But if the enemy incline towards peace, do thou (also) incline towards peace, and trust in God: for He is One that heareth and knoweth (all things). (The Noble Quran, 8:61)"

"If thou dost stretch thy hand against me, to slay me, it is not for me to stretch my hand against thee to slay thee: for I do fear God, the cherisher of the worlds. (The Noble Quran, 5:28)"

Conclusions: Warraq really distorts to meaning of Jihad, and the so-called Jihad verses are quickly refuted as they incidate they were revealed at the time of war during the time of Prophet Muhammed (pbuh) and do not reflect on waging war on society.

Further Rebuttals

Further Rebuttals

Although I have addressed this already, I further looked into this issue in Ibn Warraq’s book. On page 216 of his book, he tells of the incident of the Banu Qurayza where the Jews were executed. Although men were executed, women and children were spared. The reason for this was for treason. What Warraq does is that he tries to make it like Prophet Mohammed (PBUH) just randomly ordered that these people be killed. Of course this is not true, as the warriors Banu Qurayza were executed for treason against the Islamic state of Madinah. Looking further into this, in Madinah, there were two Arab tribes and three Jewish tribes. So not everyone was Jewish in Madinah.

Further in 622, Prophet Muhammed and the Muslims of Makka migrated to Madinah in order to secure freedom of religion and freedom from persecution. The first Islamic state was born when Prophet Muhammed entered Makka. Moreover the Jews of Madinah were one community with the Muslisms and were allowed to practice their own religion. So one can see that Prophet Muhammed had reasons to kill the Jews of the Banu Qurayza and not all Jews were killed, only the warriors as this hadith incidates:


Volume 5, Book 58, Number 148:
Narrated Abu Said Al-Khudri:
Some people (i.e. the Jews of Bani bin Quraiza) agreed to accept the verdict of Sad bin Muadh so the Prophet sent for him (i.e. Sad bin Muadh). He came riding a donkey, and when he approached the Mosque, the Prophet said, "Get up for the best amongst you." or said, "Get up for your chief." Then the Prophet said, "O Sad! These people have agreed to accept your verdict." Sad said, "I judge that their warriors should be killed and their children and women should be taken as captives." The Prophet said, "You have given a judgment similar to Allah's Judgment (or the King's judgment)."
Not only that but Prophet Muhammed ordered that the captives be freed as well:

Volume 7, Book 62, Number 103:
Narrated Abu Musa:
The Prophet said, "Set the captives free, accept the invitation (to a wedding banquet), and visit the patients."

Quran “Contradiction” Explained

Quran “Contradiction” Explained:
An alleged contradiction in the Quran addressed. By Ehteshaam Gulam

Is there a contradiction between Quran 4:157 and Quran 3:144? The answer is no. The missionaries who write for answeringislam.org who stated this don’t know what they are talking about. I’ll explain.

The Quran 4:157 states: That they said (in boast), "We killed Christ Jesus the son of Mary, the Messenger of Allah";- but they killed him not, nor crucified him, but so it was made to appear to them, and those who differ therein are full of doubts, with no (certain) knowledge, but only conjecture to follow, for of a surety they killed him not:- (Quran 4:157)

The Quran 3:144 indicates: Muhammad is no more than a messenger: many Were the messenger that passed away before him. If he died or were slain, will ye then Turn back on your heels? If any did turn back on his heels, not the least harm will he do to Allah; but Allah (on the other hand) will swiftly reward those who (serve Him) with gratitude. (Quran 3:144)

The following verse is implying that MANY messengers have died before Prophet Mohammed (pbuh). It does not say ALL the messengers have died before the Prophet.
The above verse is from the Abdullah Yousef Ali Translation of the Quran. Let’s take a look at two other translations from Pickthal and Shakir:

Pickthal: Muhammad is but a messenger, messengers (the like of whom) have passed away before him. Will it be that, when he dieth or is slain, ye will turn back on your heels? He who turneth back on his heels doth no hurt to Allah, and Allah will reward the thankful. (Quran 3:144)

SHAKIR: And Muhammad is no more than a messenger; the messengers have already passed away before him; if then he dies or is killed will you turn back upon your heels? And whoever turns back upon his heels!s, he will by no means do harm to Allah in the least and Allah will reward the grateful. (Quran 3:144)

Notice how these two translators state that messengers have passed away before Prophet Mohammed and it doesn’t say ALL the messengers have passed away before Prophet Mohammed. Also notice the Pickthal’s translation which says messengers (the like of whom) have passed away before him, implying that prophets, messengers like Prophet Mohamemd such as Abraham, Moses, David, Solomon (PBUT), etc. have passed away. All these prophets were like Prophet Mohammed in many ways, and Jesus (PBUH) was a unique case and was different from other Biblical Prophets and from Prophet Mohammed peace be upon them.

Some Islamic commentors have stated that Quran 3:55 indicates that Jesus had died. Well not exactly. The following Quranic verse states:

Behold! Allah said: "O Jesus! I will take thee and raise thee to Myself and clear thee (of the falsehoods) of those who blaspheme; I will make those who follow thee superior to those who reject faith, to the Day of Resurrection: Then shall ye all return unto me, and I will judge between you of the matters wherein ye dispute. (Quran 3:55)

The verse says that Allah will take thee and raise thee, it doesn’t say that Jesus had died. It states that Jesus was raised or taken up to Allah as in agreement with sura 4:157. Moreover the Hadith clearly indicate that Jesus is still alive and will return one day:
Narrated Abu Huraira: Allah's Apostle said, "By Him in Whose Hands my soul is, surely (Jesus,) the son of Mary will soon descend amongst you and will judge mankind justly (as a Just Ruler); he will break the Cross and kill the pigs and there will be no Jizya (i.e. taxation taken from non Muslims). Money will be in abundance so that nobody will accept it, and a single prostration to Allah (in prayer) will be better than the whole world and whatever is in it." Abu Huraira added "If you wish, you can recite (this verse of the Holy Book): -- 'And there is none Of the people of the Scriptures (Jews and Christians) But must believe in him (i.e Jesus as an Apostle of Allah and a human being) Before his death. And on the Day of Judgment He will be a witness Against them." (Bukhari Volume 4 Book 5 #657)
Narrated Abu Huraira: Allah's Apostle said "How will you be when the son of Mary (i.e. Jesus) descends amongst you and he will judge people by the Law of the Quran and not by the law of Gospel (Bukhari Volume 4 Book 55 #658)
One more thing I should state, which is not the focus of this paper, but when Prophet Mohammed (peace and blessings be upon him) says Jesus, the son of Mary will soon descend, he means that Jesus will one day soon come back. So the end could be near, after all many of the signs of the day of judgment have come to pass. What it means by Jizya, since some Muslims have completely rejected this hadith, means that non Muslims will no longer take property of value from Muslims, which could mean oil, etc.
Conclusions:

The Quranic verses contains no error or contradiction. What one verse says is that Jesus was taken up alive and another says that many but not all messengers have died before Prophet Mohammed. For the some Muslims who reject the notion that Jesus will not return are completely wrong since both the Quran and the Hadith incidate that Jesus is alive and one day he will return. The Quran is a perfect book, with absouletly no error/contradiction. The same cant be said about the Bible though. The Bible contains many errors and contradictions:

Did Jesus tell his disciples everything?

For all things that I have heard of my Father I have made known unto you. John 15:15 Not really…

I have yet many things to say unto you, but ye cannot bear them now. (John 16:12)
God states that Cain will wonder the earth

A fugitive and a vagabond shalt thou be in the earth. (Genesis 4:12) Then changes his mind a few verses later

And Cain knew his wife, and she conceived, ... and he builded a city. (Genesis 4:17)
David somehow killed 700 men in chariots and 40,000 horsemen

And David slew the men of seven hundred chariots of the Syrians, and forty thousand horsemen. (2 Samuel 10:18) David went all terminator and killed a whole lot more


David slew of the Syrians seven thousand men which fought in chariots, and forty thousand footmen. (1 Chronicles 19:18)
Some people just don’t die

And Enoch walked with God: and he was not; for God took him. (Genesis 5:24

Verily, verily, I say unto you, If a man keep my saying, he shall never see death.
(John 8:51)

And whosoever liveth and believeth in me shall never die. (John 11:26) Everyone dies…


Wherefore, as by one man sin entered into the world, and death by sin; and so death passed upon all men. (Romans 5:12)

And as it is appointed unto men once to die. (Hebrews 9:27)

Drinking on the cross…

Now there was set a vessel full of vinegar: and they filled a spunge with vinegar, and put it upon hyssop, and put it to his mouth. When Jesus therefore had received the vinegar, he said, It is finished: and he bowed his head, and gave up the ghost.
(John 19:29-30)

Just say no to drinking while your dying

And they gave him to drink wine mingled with myrrh: but he received it not. (Mark: 15:23)

These are just some of the hundreds of errors/contradictions in the Bible. Maybe the Missionaries should try to clear up these errors (which they wont be able to do) instead of disperately looking for errors/contradictions in the Quran.





Notes:

All translations of the Quran were Abdullah Yousef Ali, Mohammed Pickthal and Shakir which are considered the best English translations of the Quran. All translations of the Bible were of NIV version of the Bible.

For rebuttals of Answering-Islam please visit examinethetruth.com, answering-christianity.com and bismilkallahuma.org.

Friday, February 23, 2007

Basic Rights of Women in Islam

Basic Rights of Women in Islam

In Islam, women are guaranteed rights and are even equal to men in many areas. Islam’s views on women are to liberate or free them but at the same time remind them of their spiritual responsibilities just like men. The following list represents the basic laws all Muslim countries need in order to follow Islam properly.

1. The right and duty to obtain education
2. The right to have their own independent property.
3. The right to work to earn money if they need it or want it.
4. Equality of reward for equal deeds.
5. The right to express their opinion and be heard.
6. The right to provisions from the husband for all her needs and more.
7. The right to negotiate marriage terms of her choice.
8. The right to obtain divorce from her husband, even on the grounds that she simply can't stand him. (pls note that God deeply frowns upon divorce as a solution unless there is hardly any other alternative but it does not mean that men have more right to divorce their wives than women do.)
9. The right to keep all her own money (she is not responsible to maintain any relations).
10. The right to get sexual satisfaction from her husband.
11. custody of their children after divorce
12. To refuse any marriage that does not please them

In the West, particularly in America, the subject of women in Islam holds quite a bit of negative light. As a matter of fact, Ibn Warraq makes all sorts of bogus statements about women in Islam. However since Warraq is a secularist/humanitarian I can imagine that he really doesn’t care about what other religions have to say about women. To the Jewish/Christian reader of this book, I can state that the views on women in Christianity and Judaism are not very good, in light of the Old Testament, The New Testament, Christian and Jewish history and the Talmud. Although I will not get into that here, since this book’s focus to clear up the image of women in Islam, I’ll mainly be showing that women are truly honored in Islam.

First off, Prophet Mohammed the last messenger of God, told his followers to be kind to women, as this hadith which I have already stated, incidates:
Abu Huraira (Allah be pleased with him) reported Allah's Apostle (may peace be upon him) as saying: "He who believes in Allah and the Hereafter, if he witnesses any matter he should talk in good terms about it or keep quiet. Act kindly towards woman, for woman is created from a rib, and the most crooked part of the rib is its top. If you attempt to straighten it, you will break it, and if you leave it, its crookedness will remain there. So act kindly towards women. (Translation of Sahih Muslim, The Book of Marriage (Kitab Al-Nikah), Book 008, Number 3468)"
So Prophet Mohammed is indicating that women are to be treated nicely and kindly. But one who has read Warraq’s book might argue, what about the Quranic Verse which states to beat women which would be sura 4:3. The verse is this:
Men are the protectors and maintainers of women, because Allah has given the one more (strength) than the other, and because they support them from their means. Therefore the righteous women are devoutly obedient, and guard in (the husband's) absence what Allah would have them guard. As to those women on whose part ye fear disloyalty and ill-conduct, admonish them (first), (Next), refuse to share their beds, (And last) beat them (lightly); but if they return to obedience, seek not against them Means (of annoyance): For Allah is Most High, great (above you all).(Quran 4:3)
Of note, the following verse tells that women who are ill mannered or disloyal, the first step is to admonish then, then not to share their beds, then the last step is to beat them. However read the verse carefully. After beat them, the word lightly is there. So the Quran is saying to beat them lightly after you have done the previous two steps.
Another point to be considered is the Arabic word, Udhdhribuu literally means to strike. The word beat is a rather extreme translation used, and isn’t exactly accurate. The word strike can mean a host of things such as from a powerful punch to a slight tap. Moreover the Quran does not endorse physical harm that causes injury as the following hadith maintain:
Narrated Mu'awiyah al-Qushayri: "I went to the Apostle of Allah (peace_be_upon_him) and asked him: What do you say (command) about our wives? He replied: Give them food what you have for yourself, and clothe them by which you clothe yourself, and do not beat them, and do not revile them. (Sunan Abu-Dawud, Book 11, Marriage (Kitab Al-Nikah), Number 2139)"
Narrated Mu'awiyah ibn Haydah: "I said: Apostle of Allah, how should we approach our wives and how should we leave them? He replied: Approach your tilth when or how you will, give her (your wife) food when you take food, clothe when you clothe yourself, do not revile her face, and do not beat her. (Sunan Abu-Dawud, Book 11, Marriage (Kitab Al-Nikah), Number 2138)"
Further, Prophet Mohammed also said not to beat on the face:
Narrated Salim: "....Umar said: 'The Prophet forbade beating on the face.' (Translation of Sahih Bukhari, Hunting, Slaughtering, Volume 7, Book 67, Number 449)"
Narrated AbuHurayrah: "The Prophet (peace_be_upon_him) said: When one of you inflicts a beating, he should avoid striking the face. (Sunan Abu-Dawud, Book 38, Prescribed Punishments (Kitab Al-Hudud), Number 4478)"
Of further note, the Quran indicates that men should treat women kindly and not with harshness as the following verse indicates:
"O ye who believe! Ye are forbidden to inherit women against their will. Nor should ye treat them with harshness, that ye may take away part of the dowre have given them, except where they have been guilty of open lewdness; on the contrary live with them on a footing of kindness and equity. If ye take a dislike to them it may be that ye dislike a thing, and God brings about through it a great deal of good. (Quran, 4:19)"

When it comes to rape, the person who raped a woman is to be punished not the victim as the following hadith illustrates:

Book 38, Number 4366:
Narrated Wa'il ibn Hujr:
When a woman went out in the time of the Prophet (peace_be_upon_him) for prayer, a man attacked her and overpowered (raped) her.
She shouted and he went off, and when a man came by, she said: That (man) did such and such to me. And when a company of the Emigrants came by, she said: That man did such and such to me. They went and seized the man whom they thought had had intercourse with her and brought him to her.
She said: Yes, this is he. Then they brought him to the Apostle of Allah (peace_be_upon_him).
When he (the Prophet) was about to pass sentence, the man who (actually) had assaulted her stood up and said: Apostle of Allah, I am the man who did it to her.
He (the Prophet) said to her: Go away, for Allah has forgiven you. But he told the man some good words (AbuDawud said: meaning the man who was seized), and of the man who had had intercourse with her, he said: Stone him to death.
He also said: He has repented to such an extent that if the people of Medina had repented similarly, it would have been accepted from them.
Now this is a lot more reasonable then what the Bible has to say about rape:

22 If a man is found sleeping with another man's wife, both the man who slept with her and the woman must die. You must purge the evil from Israel.
23 If a man happens to meet in a town a virgin pledged to be married and he sleeps with her, 24 you shall take both of them to the gate of that town and stone them to death—the girl because she was in a town and did not scream for help, and the man because he violated another man's wife. You must purge the evil from among you.
25 But if out in the country a man happens to meet a girl pledged to be married and rapes her, only the man who has done this shall die. 26 Do nothing to the girl; she has committed no sin deserving death. This case is like that of someone who attacks and murders his neighbor, 27 for the man found the girl out in the country, and though the betrothed girl screamed, there was no one to rescue her.
28 If a man happens to meet a virgin who is not pledged to be married and rapes her and they are discovered, 29 he shall pay the girl's father fifty shekels of silver. [c] He must marry the girl, for he has violated her. He can never divorce her as long as he lives. (Deuteronomy 22:22-29)
So the following Biblical verse is stating that when a man violates his neighbors wife, then he is to be put to death. However if a man rapes a virgin or an unmarried woman then he has to pay the victims father 50 shekels of silver and then marry her rapist. Clearly the Islamic viewpoint makes a whole lot more sense.

In regard to women allowed to exercise Free speech and to be educated the following saying of Prophet Mohammed is to be noted:

Anas reported that the Messenger of God said: “Search for knowledge is compulsory upon every Muslim male and Muslim female.” (Ibn Majah)

Of further note, Prophet Mohammed had also taught women during his time as the following hadith indicates:

Buhkari Volume 9, Book 92, Number 413:
Narrated Abu Said:
A woman came to Allah's Apostle and said, "O Allah's Apostle! Men (only) benefit by your teachings, so please devote to us from (some of) your time, a day on which we may come to you so that you may teach us of what Allah has taught you." Allah's Apostle said, "Gather on such-and-such a day at such-and-such a place." They gathered and Allah's Apostle came to them and taught them of what Allah had taught him. He then said, "No woman among you who has lost her three children (died) but that they will screen her from the Fire." A woman among them said, "O Allah's Apostle! If she lost two children?" She repeated her question twice, whereupon the Prophet said, "Even two, even two, even two!"
As noted previously, the laws of marriage and divorce have already been discussed. So women are given a pretty comfortable place in Islam and the former Taliban regime of Afghanistan does not reflect Islamic teachings along with other Muslim countries which treat women harshly and unkindly.

Thursday, February 22, 2007

Bibliography

Bibliography

Some articles obtained with permission by the following sites:

http://www.answering-christianity.com
http://www.islamicawareness.com
http://www.faithfreedom.com
http://www.bismikaallahuma.org/
http://www.harunyahya.com/

Metzger, Bruce,"The Text of the New Testament-- Its Transmission, Corruption, and Restoration," Oxford University Press, 1968

Leedom, Tim C. "The Book Your Church Doesn't Want You To Read," Kendall/Hunt Publishing Company, 1993

Helms, Randel McCraw , "Who Wrote the Gospels?", Millennium Press

The Complete Idiots Guide to Understanding Islam By Yahya Emerick Second Edition 2004

Understanding Islam: A Guide for the Judeao- Christian Reader By Jerald F. Dirks Amana Publishers, 2003

Abdullah Yousef Ali Translation of the Quran, copyright 2000

Further Sites Refuting the Propaganda

Other sites refuting the Anti-Islamic propaganda:
http://www.islamic-awareness.org

http://www.IslamLife.com
http://www.bismikaallahuma.org

http://www.MuslimAccess.Com
http://www.invitationtothetruth.com
http://www.cair-net.org
http://www.answering-christianity.com

http://www.faithfreedom.com

http://www.thetruereligion.org/missionary.htm

http://www.islamic.org.uk/

http://www.muslim-answers.org/

http://www.sharif.org.uk/

http://www.guidedones.com/

http://www.understanding-islam.org/

http://www.ExamineTheTruth.com (Good site)

http://www.muslim-responses.com

http://islamanswersback.phpbbnow.com/index.php?sid=1cb5c16a4b4e6fc439497b554ae24000

http://www.why-christians-convert-to-islam.com/

http://www.towardsislam.com/

Other Reviews on Ibn Warraq, Conclusions, Refuting the Propaganda

Review of Ibn Warraq’s “The Quest for the Historical Muhammad”

In 2000, Ibn Warraq had published the Book “The Quest for the Historical Mohammed”. To be honest that book is worse than his first one, Why I am Not a Muslim. And I am not the only one who thinks so. Fred M. Donner of the University of Chicago also agrees. He wrote a review of the book. Here it is, take from a non muslim on Warraq’s book and judge for yourself:

The study of Islam's origins, including the life of Muhammad, is a notoriously contentious undertaking. Scholars with admirable training differ sharply among themselves on how to understand it. The appearance of a volume that claims to provide "sufficient background to put the current debates, between revisionists and traditionalists about the origins of Islam, in their intellectual context" (p. 9) is thus sure to attract notice.

Unfortunately, the compiler, identified only by the pseudonym "Ibn Warraq", who also wrote the volume's long introductory essay, is triply unqualified to serve as our guide in this field. "Ibn Warraq" like the equally mysterious author of the second essay, on the sources, "Ibn Rawandi" (perhaps one and the same individual?) lacks the rigorous specialist training in Arabic studies that alone could qualify him (her?) to evaluate independently the different schools of interpretation in this field. This inadequacy is revealed by, for example, inconsistent handling of Arabic materials, and by the fact that neither "Ibn Warraq" nor "Ibn Rawandi" contributes any original arguments to this debate.

More serious still is the compiler's heavy-handed favoritism for certain revisionist theories (particularly those of John Wansbrough), resulting in a thoroughly one-sided selection of articles and translations that constitute the bulk of the volume. These include works, mostly well-known, by Ernest Renan, Henri Lammens (including a complete translation of his monograph "Fatima and the Daughters of Muhammad"), C. H. Becker, Arthur Jeffery, Joseph Schacht, Lawrence I. Conrad, Andrew Rippin, J. Koren and Y. D. Nevo, F. E. Peters, Herbert Berg, and G. R. Hawting. Most of these were landmark contributions to the lengthy debate on the origins of Islam, by scholars who had (have) strong opinions about it and were possessed of full mastery of the primary languages (especially Arabic) and sources.

"Ib Warraq's" bias, however, causes him to omit fine contributions that pose challenges for some revisionist ideas by H. Motzki, U. Rubin, and many others. This lopsided character makes The Quest for the Historical Muhammad a book that is likely to mislead many an unwary general reader.

Most problematic of all, however, is the compiler's agenda, which is not scholarship, but anti-Islam polemic. The author of an earlier book entitled Why I Am Not a Muslim (1995), "Ibn Warraq" and his co-conspirator "Ibn al-Rawandi" detest anything that, to them, smacks of apologetic; for this reason they criticize harshly several noted authors for their 'bad faith' or 'moral ambiguity.'

Yet this book is itself a monument to duplicity. The compiler never has the honesty or courage to divulge his identity, even though a list of contributors (pp. 551-54) gives a biographical sketch of all the other contributors who, unlike "Ibn Warraq" and "Ibn al-Rawandi", are already well-known.

Far more serious is the fact that this book is religious polemic attempting to masquerade as scholarship. It is a collection of basically sound articles, framed by a seriously flawed introduction, and put in the service of anti-Islamic polemic dedicated to the proposition that Islam is a sham and that honest scholarship on Islam requires gratuitous rudeness to Muslim sensibilities.

By associating these articles with "Ibn Warraq's" polemical agenda, The Quest for the Historical Muhammad will raise suspicions among some Muslims that all revisionist scholarship is motivated by such intolerance.

This is likely to make the future progress of sound historical scholarship on Islam's origins harder, rather than easier. The publication of The Quest for the Historical Muhammad is, therefore, a most unfortunate event.

More Rebuttals:

The Origins of the Koran: Classic Essays on Islam's Holy Book

BOOK’s Critical REVIEW by Prof Y. Dutton, lecturer in the department of Islamic Studies, University of Edinburgh, taken from the Journal of Islamic Studies, May 2000 edition. (Oxford Centre for Islamic Studies, 2000)

This book, edited by the rather nebulous personage of "Ibn Warraq" (neither his full name nor his institutional affiliation, if any, are anywhere given), consists of thirteen previously published essays on the history and nature of the Qur'anic text, twelve of them dating from the half-century between 1890 and 1940 and only the thirteenth dating from as recently as 1985. The book is divided into four parts. Part One contains an Introduction by the editor which summarises recent, mostly "revisionist", Western scholarship on the origins of the Islam and its written tradition, and also a general essay, described in the blurb rather grandiosely and, one has to say, rather nonsensically as "the first truly scientific study of the Qur'an; by Theodor Noldeke. Part Two, "The Collection and the Variants of the Koran; consists of essays by Leone Caetani, Alphonse Mingana (two), Arthur Jeffrey (four) and David Margoliouth, on the general theme of how the present text came to be established. Part three, "The Sources of the Koran"; presents three long essays by Abraham Geiger, W. St Clair-Tisdall and Charles Torrey, all of which explore the supposed Jewish, Christian, and Zoroastrian sources of the Qur'an. Part Four, "Modern Textual Criticisms of the Koran"; consists of a single essay by Andrew Rippin, the only contemporary scholar represented in the collection, which presents the methodologies of John Wansbrough and his use of literary analysis to question the standard Muslim dating of the earliest Islamic texts.

The problem with this collection is its orientation. The editor purports to be concerned only with "those truths that are yielded by a process of rational enquiry, by scientific examination" (9), ostensibly to achieve, in Arthur Jeffrey's words, a "critical investigation of the text of the Qu'ran" (9). However, what we see exhibited by the choice of essays is in fact quite different. Ibn Warraq himself rejects most, if not all, Muslim scholarship on the issue, while at the same time seeming to accept without question anything produced by the "revisionist" wing of modern Western scholarship, neither of which positions would seem tenable for one seeking to produce by "rational enquiry". Moreover, he seems to have ignored even that amount of criticism of the "revisionist" position that exists in his own chosen essays: thus, for example, in his Introduction he praises the work of Crone and Cook, whose book Hagarism he describes as "fascinating" (33) and "intellectually exhilarating" (29), without seeming to be aware of Rippin's caveat elsewhere in the collection that "although they (Crone and Cook) successfully draw attention to the problems involved in the study of Islam, they have not been able to get beyond the limitations in the sources, for they are all of questionable historical authenticity and, more importantly, all are treatises based in polemic" (352). In other words, the non-Islamic sources are no more free from potential bias than the Muslim ones. Indeed, the words that best seem to describe Ibn Warraq's attitude are those that he quotes from Rippin, who refers to those who approach Islam "with less than academic candour" (10), and Crone, who warns us that "the entire tradition is tendentious; which, although intended to refer to Muslim historiography, applies as much, if not more so, to modern revisionist scholarship.

But not only is Ibn Warraq's own position "based on polemic" and an uncritical acceptance of certain sources (in this case, modern revisionist scholarship), but so too are the highly "Christianised" critiques - or attempts at critique - of, for example, Mingana and St Clair-Tisdall, for whom nothing is ultimately acceptable unless it accords with Christian scripture (e.g. 79, 235, 259), and for whom, it seems, "the opinions of Arab authors?are too worthless to be quoted" (95). Similar assumptions of the primacy of Judaism and/or Christianity also seem to underlie many if not most of the other essays in the book. However, what in fact for the majority of these essays show is not a Jewish, Christian, or even Zoroastrian, source for some Qur'anic narrative or narratives (one is reminded of how the unbelievers in the Qur'anic narrative always reject the Qur'an as "tales of the ancients"), but rather the existence of parallels: any conclusions about direct borrowing in a derivatory sense are, and can only remain, speculation.

Nevertheless, there is some benefit to be gained from this book. This reviewer in particular found the essays by Jeffrey and Margoliouth on the variants of the Qu'ran (Chapter 6 and 10 respectively) to be of more than passing interest in that they collect together many useful references and suggest many lines for future research. But otherwise, this book is lacking in interest for the serious scholar of "the origins of the Koran"; for the simple reason that it seems to miss, or bypass, the essential issue of the nature of revelation itself and the claims made about it. Put simply, either the Prophet was telling the truth or he wasn't. Again and again the Qur'an emphasises that this is not the speech of a mere human but rather "a sending down from the Lord of all the worlds". Now, either the Prophet was correct in his accepting and saying this or he was not; and if he was not, then either he was inadvertently mistaken or he was an outright impostor. To countenance his being an impostor does not, quite frankly, tally with everything we know of the excellence of his human behaviour, nor does it tally with the love that others had for him and the spirit of self-sacrifice expressed so clearly by all who took his path. Nor can we accept that he was mistaken: it is recorded that when he first experienced the phenomenon of revelation, he was afraid that he might be going mad. His wife, Khadija, however, had the decisive argument on that point: it did not make sense that someone who so selflessly looked after the sick and the poor, helped those in need, and treated his guests and neighbours well-in short, someone who was always so outgoing and helpful to others-should be mad. Madness and altruism do not go together. Rather, it is outward social action that indicates a deep sanity in the human being.

Either one accepts this argument of Khadija, along with the testimony of tradition to the Prophet's honesty and trustworthiness both before and after the onset of his revelationary experiences, bolstered by the evidence of the unconditional love that he engendered in those around him-which is hardly the effect of a liar and a cheat-or one does not. As for his being mistaken, either one rejects the testimony on his own tongue that the Qu'ran was revealed "on his heart" and was then expressed outwardly by his own speech but was nevertheless the "sending down of the Lord of all the worlds" and not of his own volition, or one does not. And either one accepts Khadija's argument that someone with such praiseworthy outward behaviour-the basic mark of sanity-could not be the object of demonic possession but rather was in full possession of his faculties, or one does not.

If one takes the Muslim position and accepts these arguments-or rather we should say positions, since there is no argument about these points but rather a recognition and acceptance of them-then the nature of revelation is defined by what actually happened, rather than by any expectations people might have about what they think should have happened. One can impose no prior expectations on this material: rather, the nature of the revelation is at it was, variants and all. And with respect to this latter point, we should remember that Muslim scholars have never been embarrassed by the presence of variants, not even the Shadhdh, or non-standard ones: rather, they have accepted their existence, and the fact that people used them at the time they did, while at the same recognising that there was a need to simplify and systematise matters for latter generations to prevent an unacceptable proliferation, thus leading first to "Uthman's decision to restrict the written form of the Qur'an so that, as the reports put it, "the community would not become divided about their scripture as had the Jews and Christians", and, secondly, to the subsequent systematisation of the various possibilities into the accepted systems of the Seven, Ten, or even Fourteen, Readers.

From this perspective, the contents of the present book seem little more than a polemical attempt to debunk the Qur'an and, by extension, Islam. As St Clair-Tisdall put it in his essay on the supposed Jewish, Christian and Zoroastrian sources of the Qur'an: "If we can trace the teaching of the Koran, or any part of it, to an earthly source, or to human systems existing previous to the Prophet's age, then Islam at once falls to the ground" (232; cf.227, where William Muir, in his Introduction to the same piece, repeats the same claim). The rest of the book is not, as we have suggested above, in a very different mode.

Rather, it seems to me that one has to accept a reality of revelation, experienced and mediated not only by the Prophet Muhammad but also by many, many Prophets and Messengers before him. From this perspective, one would indeed expect a great deal of similarity in content between previous divinely inspired messages. But it remains true that, of these messages, that which we know today as the Qu'ran is our best and most complete example and therefore the best starting point for anyone who wants to better understand this phenomenon.